Cheap Flights from New York to Milwaukee Starting at $158

John F. Kennedy International (JFK) serves as New York’s primary international gateway and a major transatlantic hub, typically handling long-haul, premium and full-service carriers alongside some low-cost operators. Located about 16 miles from Midtown Manhattan, travel to the city center is usually 45–75 minutes by taxi or rideshare depending on traffic, with fares commonly ranging higher than airport shuttles; the AirTrain links to NYC subway and Long Island Rail Road, adding 40–60 minutes at modest combined fares. Pros: extensive international routes and full-service amenities; cons: can be busy and subject to heavy traffic for ground transfers. Newark Liberty International (EWR) functions as a significant international and domestic hub for airlines that often emphasize transcontinental and global connections, and can be perceived as price-competitive for some carriers. Situated in New Jersey about 16 miles from Midtown Manhattan, journey times to Manhattan are typically 30–60 minutes by taxi or rideshare, though traffic can extend that; the AirTrain connects to NJ Transit and Amtrak with total travel times around 30–50 minutes at moderate fares. Pros: strong long-haul network and alternative to NYC airports; cons: located across state lines which can complicate transfers and ground travel times. LaGuardia Airport (LGA) is usually positioned as New York’s primary short-haul and domestic airport, favored by many budget and full-service carriers operating U.S. and Canadian routes. Only about 8 miles from Midtown Manhattan, transfers are commonly 20–40 minutes by taxi or rideshare in typical traffic, with lower taxi fares than farther airports; there are also buses and planned rail connections that can add time but are generally lower cost. Pros: proximity to Manhattan and quick domestic connections; cons: fewer long-haul flights, compact terminals, and peak-hour congestion can affect comfort and punctuality.

Fly nonstop from New York to Milwaukee for the quickest, most convenient way to reach Wisconsin — fewer hassles, no layovers, and more time for what matters. While connecting options can sometimes be cheaper, direct flights save hours and offer a more comfortable, stress-free journey, making them a smart choice for both business and leisure travelers.

The route New York — Milwaukee is served by many carriers — 4 in total, including United Airlines, Frontier Airlines, Southwest Airlines, and JetBlue Airways. This gives passengers wide opportunities: from finding the lowest fare (from $158) to selecting flights by schedule or service class. Our service aggregates data from multiple booking systems so you can compare offers in one place. This saves time and money: no need to check dozens of sites — just pick the right option and book online.

Milwaukee Mitchell International Airport (MKE) serves as the region’s primary commercial gateway, typically handling a mix of legacy carriers and low-cost airlines on domestic and some seasonal routes. It is usually perceived as more budget-friendly than larger hubs, with fares often competitive for Midwest travel. The airport lies about 9 miles south of downtown Milwaukee; shuttle and taxi rides can take roughly 15–25 minutes depending on traffic, while public transit via bus routes may take 30–50 minutes for a lower fare. Rental cars and ride-hailing are widely available. Pros: compact terminal, short walking distances, and generally quick security; cons: fewer nonstop long-haul options and limited international connectivity compared with major hubs.

In different months, ticket prices from New York to Milwaukee vary: minimum — $117 (November 2025), maximum — $185 (December 2025). Typically, the flight costs $151–$185.