Cheap Flights from New York to Indianapolis Starting at $41

We carefully collect statistics on the search and pricing of airlines and, based on these data, we make an assumption about future prices. Thus, you can better understand which season is the cheapest to fly from New York to Indianapolis

John F. Kennedy International (JFK) is New York’s primary international gateway and a major long‑haul hub for legacy carriers and many global airlines, while also serving some low‑cost operators. It’s typically perceived as mid‑to‑upper range on fares compared with other local options. JFK sits about 15 miles southeast of Midtown Manhattan; typical transport choices include AirTrain plus Long Island Rail Road or subway (roughly 35–60 minutes, fares around $10–$20), shuttle buses, taxis and ride‑shares (30–60 minutes, fares vary considerably). Pros: extensive international connections and full‑service amenities; cons: can be busy, with longer transfer and security times. LaGuardia Airport (LGA) functions mainly as a domestic and short‑haul airport, traditionally favored by business travelers and carriers focused on intra‑US routes. It is often seen as a convenient but budget‑sensitive option for regionally priced flights. Located about 8 miles from Midtown Manhattan, ground transfer is usually fastest: taxis or ride‑shares take 20–40 minutes depending on traffic (fares vary), and several bus services connect to subway lines for total journeys of 30–60 minutes with modest ticket costs. Pros: proximity to Manhattan and frequent short‑haul flights; cons: limited long‑haul service and periodic congestion or construction delays. Newark Liberty International (EWR) serves as a major hub for several full‑service carriers and handles a high share of international and transcontinental flights to the New York metro. It tendsto be price-competitive for certain routes, often offering alternatives to JFK for similar itineraries. Located in New Jersey about 16 miles southwest of Midtown Manhattan, transport options include AirTrain plus NJ Transit trains (about 30–50 minutes, fares generally in the mid single‑digits to low double digits), buses, taxis and ride‑shares (35–60 minutes, fares variable). Pros: strong rail links and often efficient operations; cons: distance from Manhattan and occasional heavy traffic on access roads.

Indianapolis International Airport (IND) serves as the city’s primary commercial gateway and typically functions as a mid-sized national hub rather than a major global transfer point. You’ll commonly find a mix of legacy carriers and low-cost airlines operating scheduled flights; fares can be perceived as competitive for domestic connections. The airport is about 10 miles (16 km) southwest of downtown Indianapolis and reachable by taxi or rideshare in roughly 20–30 minutes, or by local shuttle services that may take a similar time; fares usually range from modest flat rates to metered taxi charges. Travelers benefit from a compact single-terminal layout that can make connections straightforward, though peak periods may bring longer lines at security. Public buses and rental cars are available for budget-minded visitors, while limited direct rail options mean most passengers rely on road transport.

More than 5 airlines operate flights from New York to Indianapolis, including United Airlines, Spirit Airlines, Republic Airlines, Frontier Airlines, and Southwest Airlines. This is a popular route, so passengers can choose tickets based on budget and preferences. Ticket prices start from $41, and our service lets you instantly compare all options. The variety of offers simplifies planning: you can choose budget fares or more comfortable options with baggage included or extra services. We help you find the best deals so your trip is cost-efficient.